How to Answer Question 2 in Paper 3
with exemplar

Travis DixonAssessment (IB), Example Exam Answers, Revision and Exam Preparation

A step-by-step guide to scoring top marks in Q2 Paper 3.

This post explains how to write a top-scoring answer for Question 2 in Paper 3. 

We’ll start by understanding what examiners are looking for and work backwards to writing the perfect answer.

TL;DR:

  • Find six points in the data to comment on.
  • State the findings and explain what they suggest about the study and/or the claim.
  • Write a clear conclusion based on the findings and link it to the claim.

Example Answer

The following answer is based on this practice paper.

The data in Source 2 is consistent with the claim that studying with technology-based resources can have a negative impact on learning.

The graph shows that students who took notes by typing scored slightly better on average on factual recall questions. This suggests typing notes might be better for factual recall. However, these differences are not statistically significant because the p value (0.91) is greater than 0.05. This means the findings could be random and not because of the effect of the IV – note-taking style.

On the other hand, there was a statistically significant difference (p<0.03) between note-taking type and conceptual application questions – the handwriting group scored much better compared to the typing group. This suggests handwriting notes is better for understanding more abstract content. This might be explained by the number of words and amount of verbatim copying from the TED Talks – the typing group wrote out on average almost double (309) the number of words than the handwriting group (173). However, there was a much wider range of words typed for the typing group as shown by the larger standard deviation – 116.5 compared to 70. This could be due to variations in individual typing speeds. Because people wrote more and copied exactly more from the lecture (14.6% compared to 8.8%), it means they might just be copying things down exactly rather than thinking carefully and taking the key points. This could be why they remembered more facts but then couldn’t understand the conceptual information as well.

Overall, the data shows that taking notes by typing is an inferior studying technique when understanding concepts from new and unfamiliar material, which is consistent with the claim that studying with technology-based resources can have a negative impact on learning. (350 words)

Structure

The above answer follows this simple structure:

Broad opening

  • General statement about the source, study or claim to open the response (Optional)

Analytical points:

  1. Point 1 – e.g. comparing average scores
  2. Point 2 – e.g. comparing spread
  3. Point 3 – e.g. skew
  4. Point 4 –e.g. graph analysis
  5. Point 5 – e.g p values
  6. Point 6 – e.g Missing data

Conclusion

  1. What do the findings suggest about behaviour?
  2. How do these findings relate to the claim?

The Rubric 

Examiners use the rubrics to mark your answer. In Q2 the rubric states you have to do two things:

  • Analyse the data
  • Draw a conclusion

Let’s compare a low scoring answer with a high scoring one using the IB’s rubric.

  • Low scoring: Limited analysis with an irrelevant conclusion
  • High scoring: Detailed analysis with a clear conclusion linked to the findings

Next I’ll explain exactly how to write a detailed analysis and a clear conclusion.

Detailed Analysis

Two things make an analysis detailed – quantity and quality.

  • Quantity: You can’t have a detailed analysis by focusing on one datapoint. Therefore, I recommend aiming to make six points about the data (because it’s worth 6 marks). If you can’t find 6 then 5 will do.
  • Quality: A list of 5-6 statements about the data won’t help either – you have to explain them.  Here’s my advice on how to do that.

Follow these steps for a detailed analysis:

  1. Annotate
  2. Plan
  3. Write

I would expect a student’s resource booklet to look like this. Annotate the paper carefully to find the most relevant points to make.

Step 1 – Annotate: Annotate and highlight the source in the resource booklet. Identify relevant and interesting things to comment on. In order of importance these includes:

  • Mean, median and mode comparisons
  • Spread comparisons (range, interquartile range, etc)
  • Statistical significance (p-values)
  • Correlations
  • Effect sizes
  • Skewness

Step 2 – Plan: Note down the points you’re going to make. Start with those you can explain the best. Work your way down. By the time you finish annotating the paper you should be able to draw a conclusion from the data.

Step 3 – Write your answer. As you’re writing make sure you’re explaining each point. Use phrases such as:

      • This suggests that…
      • This could mean that…
      • This shows…
      • This may be because…
      • This indicates…
        • Avoid saying “this proves…” A single dataset or study cannot prove a psychological claim.

Example:

  • The following example explanation is based on the data from Source 2 in the IB’s specimen paper.
    • Weak Example: The mean and median in the HST condition were similar (11.6 and 10), as were the mean and median in the NST condition (17.64 and 15). The graph shows…” 
    • Improved Example: The mean and median in the HST condition were similar (11.6 and 10). This suggests that outliers may not have skewed the data. The same can be said for the NST condition which also had similar means and medians (17.64 and 15). This could also mean the data is normally distributed. That said, the graph shows…”

Notice how the weak example just states the findings whereas the stronger example adds an explanation of what that finding suggests.

Here are a few more example sentences:

  • The mean scores in Condition A were similar to Condition B, which suggests….
  • The p-value was >0.05, which means…
  • The range in Group B was 24 compared to just 10 in Group A, which shows…

Clear Conclusion

So far you’ve analysed the results of the study – this is what happened with the participants. The conclusion is what these results suggest about real-world behaviour. Here are two examples from famous studies you may know:

Bandura’s Bobo Doll:

  • Results: Kids in the aggressive model condition acted more aggressively towards the bobo doll than the control and passive conditions.
  • Conclusion: Observing aggressive behaviour could increase levels of aggression in children.

Milgram’s Obedience Study:

  • Results: 65% of participants complied with the researcher’s request to shock the participant all the way to 450 volts.
  • Conclusion: Most people may be willing to comply with authority figures even if it means potentially killing someone.

Link to Findings and Claim

The conclusion should be clearly based on the findings of the study. That’s the first part of the conclusion. I recommend then linking it to the claim made in the source paper. Here’s an example based on this example paper:

  • Overall, the data shows that taking notes by typing is an inferior studying technique when learning new and unfamiliar material, which is consistent with the claim that studying with technology-based resources can have a negative impact on learning. (350 words). Read the full example answer here.

The best way to prepare for Paper 3 is to do lots of practice papers. Teachers can find them in our teacher support packs here.

Download an entire unit plan for teaching HL students everything they need for Paper 3. (READ MORE)